Pizza restaurants

Pie O My Pizzeria

4.5 82 reviews 77 Main St, Sundridge, ON P0A 1Z0, Canada

Discover this place

Yettis Pizza Sundridge is a locally rooted pizza restaurant located at 77 Main St, Sundridge, ON. It offers a menu centered around authentic and Canadian-style pizzas, featuring a range of toppings such as banana peppers, pepperoni, ham, and bacon. In addition to its signature pizzas, the menu includes classic cold cut subs, providing a variety of casual dining options. The atmosphere at Yettis is inviting and friendly, designed to cater to both residents and visitors seeking a relaxed place to enjoy a meal. The focus remains on delivering well-crafted, flavorful pizzas made with quality ingredients. Yettis Pizza Sundridge stands out as a notable spot for those in search of traditional pizza flavors with a local touch, reflecting the community’s appreciation for straightforward, satisfying comfort food in a welcoming environment.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Seating

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pie O My Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Pie O My Pizzeria

4.5

82 reviews

100%

17%

Review highlights

Based on 82 reviews

Yettis Pizza Sundridge consistently receives praise for its delicious, high-quality pizzas that notably combine flavorful sauces, fresh cheese, and well-balanced crusts. Customers frequently highlight the restaurant’s welcoming and friendly staff, contributing to a warm and positive dining atmosphere. Service reliability, including timely order preparation, is commonly appreciated, enhancing the overall experience. While the pizza size occasionally falls short of expectations for some patrons, the taste and affordability remain strong selling points. Repeat visits and recommendations from tourists reflect a growing loyal customer base. Overall, Yettis Pizza Sundridge is recognized for delivering exceptional pizza quality alongside attentive service, creating a gratifying experience for both locals and visitors alike.

Marce T

Aug 06, 2025

I wanted to provide some feedback on the pizza order we placed with your restaurant recently. We called in our order and were pleased that the pizza was ready on time, which we appreciated. The pizza itself was delicious, and we thoroughly enjoyed the taste. However, we were a bit surprised to find that the large pizza we ordered seemed smaller than expected. While the quality was great, we found the size to be a bit smaller than what we had anticipated for a large pizza. We are regular customers of your establishment and have always been satisfied with the service and food quality. We thought it important to bring this issue to your attention as we believe it may have been a misunderstanding. We look forward to continuing to enjoy your delicious pizzas and appreciate your attention to this matter.

Desiree Connell

Jul 09, 2025

Wow, best pizza I have had in a long time. We are tourists and come this way a couple times a year and will most definitely be getting pizza from here everytime. Thank You ! Great service and incredible pizza !

Veronica Ouias

Jul 08, 2025

This place is just amzing. Great staff super kind and friendly. The server's Hayley and Anjali and so sweet and helpful. The pizza was amzing to by far one of the best pizzas I've ever had. super delicious there specials never disappoint same with there regular ones I've gone here at lest 15 times in the past month. it's not crazy expensive nice and affordable. I love this restaurant so much and I hope everyone elses enjoys it as much as me if your ever in the area I'm begging you please stop by you won't be disappointed!

Kym

Jul 04, 2025

Stayed at Caswell Resort for my birthday weekend and were recommended pizza from your store. Had the Northern Hawaiian and omg !!! The best, absolutely the best. My husband and I couldn't stop eating it and an XL that would normally have leftovers did not happen. So good....the sauce, the cheese, the maple ......just delicious. Wanted to take a pizza home the next day (Sunday) but sadly they were not open until 4:00 pm

Karen Weber

Jul 02, 2025

Yummm delicious pizza - we visited in July 2022 from out of town and was impressed with their pizza. Loved everything about it - crust, cheese, sauce! Worked so well together. Def recommend!!!

Taylor Self

Jun 12, 2025

Got the Northern Hawaiian pizza and it was delicious. The maple glazed crust was a nice touch and very tasty. Will definitely be adding this to my meal list for all my future visits.